The Aaron Rodgers experiment in New York unofficially came to an end on February 13 when the team announced that they were parting ways with the future Hall of Fame quarterback after two uneventful seasons. For a franchise that has struggled for over a decade to find a consistent signal-caller, this latest setback places the Jets at yet another crossroads.
With a roster brimming with potential on both sides of the ball and a front office eager to end the NFL’s longest active playoff drought—having not made the postseason since 2010—the Jets must make their next move carefully. Should they bet on a veteran quarterback with experience? Or would a young, high-upside player provide a better long-term solution?
With several names set to hit the free-agent market and the NFL Draft looming in April, the Jets have multiple options to explore. But regardless of the direction they take, they need a quarterback who can not only guide them to the playoffs but also help them compete once they get there. Here’s a look at the top five realistic options the Jets could wager on to replace Aaron Rodgers in 2025.
Kirk Cousins: The Proven Veteran
If the Jets are looking for a quarterback who can help them win immediately, Kirk Cousins might be their best bet. A four-time Pro Bowler, Cousins has been one of the league’s most consistent passers over the past decade, capable of making big plays and leading an efficient offense.
Before an Achilles injury ended his 2023 season, Cousins was putting together one of the best statistical years of his career, throwing for over 2,300 yards with 18 touchdowns and just five interceptions in only eight games. As a member of the Atlanta Falcons in 2024, Cousins bounced back, recording a 7-7 season with 18 touchdowns and 3508 yards.
However, the biggest hurdle might be financial. Cousins will be one of the most sought-after free agents on the market, and his price tag might be more than New York wants to pay. The Jets already have financial commitments to Rodgers and other key players, meaning they’d have to maneuver their cap space wisely.
Justin Fields: The High-Upside Playmaker
After an up-and-down tenure with the Chicago Bears, Justin Fields found himself in Pittsburgh last season, where he split the QB1 role with Russell Wilson. Now set to enter free agency, Fields still has a lot to prove. At just 25 years old, he brings a dual-threat element to the game that few quarterbacks possess.
Fields’ biggest issue has been consistency. While he has flashed brilliance, particularly as a runner, his decision-making and accuracy have been concerns. Still, his physical tools make him an intriguing option, and given his age, he could be a long-term solution for a team willing to develop him properly.
The odds of Fields landing with the Jets depend on whether the Steelers decide to keep him. If he becomes available, the Jets could make a play for him, especially if they believe he offers more upside than their current in-house options.
