The Indianapolis Colts are heading into the 2025 season with a major decision looming at the most important position in football: quarterback. After a turbulent 2024 season, the team finds itself with two potential starters—Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones—vying for the top spot. With both players facing their own hurdles, this competition is set to define not only the upcoming campaign but also the franchise’s long-term future.
Anthony Richardson – Indianapolis Colts Quarterback – ESPN
Richardson’s Rocky Start
Anthony Richardson entered the NFL with immense potential as the Colts’ fourth overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft. However, injuries limited him to just four starts in his rookie year, and his sophomore season in 2024 was far from impressive. He struggled with accuracy, completing only 47.7% of his passes while throwing for 1,814 yards, eight touchdowns, and 12 interceptions. These numbers raise concerns about his consistency and ability to lead the offense effectively.
Despite his struggles, Richardson’s physical gifts remain undeniable. His arm strength and athleticism give him a high ceiling, but his development has been hindered by injuries and a lack of on-field experience. With a full offseason ahead, the pressure is on for Richardson to prove he can be the Colts’ franchise quarterback.
Daniel Jones Stats, News and Video – QB | NFL.com
Jones’ Fresh Start in Indianapolis
On the other side of the competition is Daniel Jones, a veteran with a roller-coaster career of his own. After signing a lucrative extension with the New York Giants, Jones struggled to live up to expectations and was ultimately benched in 2024 after a disappointing 2-8 record. His season ended with a respectable 63.3% completion rate, throwing for 2,070 yards, eight touchdowns, and seven interceptions. However, turnovers and inconsistency have plagued him throughout his career.
Now in Indianapolis, Jones has an opportunity to resurrect his career in a new system. While he brings experience and a proven ability to manage an offense, he must show he can be more than just a game manager. If he outperforms Richardson in training camp and preseason action, he could seize the starting job for Week 1.
Daniel Jones vs. Anthony Richardson for starting QB is about to be a mid-off Jones > Richardson?
The Competition Heats Up
As training camp approaches, the Colts will closely evaluate both quarterbacks. Linebacker Zaire Franklin has already emphasized that competition will be key to improvement, pushing both players to elevate their performances. The coaching staff will be looking for consistency, decision-making, and leadership as determining factors in the battle for QB1.
Richardson has the edge in terms of long-term potential, but if he falters, Jones’ experience and steadier play could earn him the job. The preseason will be a proving ground, with each throw and each decision under scrutiny.
What’s at Stake?
This quarterback battle is more than just a short-term decision—it’s about the Colts’ future. If Richardson can overcome his accuracy issues and take a leap forward, he solidifies himself as the franchise’s cornerstone. But if he struggles, the Colts may have to consider alternative plans, whether that means relying on Jones for stability or looking toward the 2026 draft for another option.
Who’ll Be the Colts Starter: Anthony Richardson or Daniel Jones? – Last Word on Pro Football
For Jones, this may be his last chance to secure a starting role in the NFL. A strong performance could revive his career, while continued struggles might cement his status as a backup moving forward.
Bottom Line
The Colts’ quarterback competition between Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones is one of the most intriguing storylines heading into the 2025 season. With Richardson’s raw potential clashing against Jones’ experience, the battle for the starting job will shape the team’s trajectory. Whether it’s a comeback story for Jones or a breakout year for Richardson, Colts fans are in for a compelling offseason—and a critical decision that could define their franchise’s future
