The Indianapolis Colts are under increasing scrutiny as third-year quarterback Anthony Richardson continues to have difficulty with his growth. Previously regarded as a high-potential prospect, Richardson’s 2024 performance highlighted the difficulties young quarterbacks encounter when moving to the NFL.
Richardson’s performance last season was unmistakable, as he recorded a league-worst 47.7% completion rate, throwing 12 interceptions compared to only eight touchdowns. Injuries additionally obstructed his advancement, restricting him to four starts in his rookie season of 2023 and impacting his offseason training for 2024.
Though showing moments of athletic talent, his lack of consistency has resulted in the Colts having ongoing uncertainties about the game’s crucial position. This offseason, Richardson has sought to realign his path by concentrating on improving his techniques and collaborating with a biometric specialist.
Training camp reports indicate that his accuracy problems continue, underscored by a viral video of a badly thrown pass. Although Richardson minimized worries regarding a slight shoulder problem, his practice performances have not alleviated concerns about his ability to lead the team.
NFL Analysis Provides Candid Evaluation of Indianapolis Colts’ Anthony Richardson
Richardson’s prospects for the 2025 NFL season aren’t as optimistic as Indianapolis supporters anticipated. An analysis by Alex Kay for Bleacher Report provides more details on this.
The Indianapolis Colts will soon need to confront reality and recognize that their costly investment in Anthony Richardson is unlikely to succeed.
It’s difficult to fault the Colts for being enamored with the incredibly athletic quarterback in the run-up to the 2023 draft. He amazed evaluators with a record-breaking display at the combine, and it likely wasn’t hard for Indy’s leadership to picture him excelling at that same Lucas Oil Stadium on Sundays.
That choice has plagued the Colts for the past two seasons as it has become painfully evident that Richardson simply isn’t an NFL-level quarterback. The indications were present before the draft—he played only one complete season at Florida, a year where he managed a meager 53.8 percent completion rate—but the expectation was that he could improve this aspect of his game to enhance his remarkable athleticism and running skills.
Although Richardson displayed potential as a rookie, injuries restricted him to just four starts. He declined markedly in Year 2, completing a poor 47.7 percent of passes and tossing more interceptions (12) than touchdowns (8).
Indianapolis has secured its options by signing veteran Daniel Jones to a one-year contract to challenge for the starting position. Jones, despite his experience, has faced his own challenges, resulting in uncertainty regarding the team’s quarterback position. Due to limited depth, the team’s offensive achievements depend on Richardson’s skill to conv
ert potential into actual results.