The Mole’s player ratings: ‘Very disappointing’ end for axed Bulldogs as season ends in disaster

Penrith have booked a spot in next weekend’s preliminary finals, scoring a massive win over the Bulldogs in front of a big crowd at Accor Stadium.

The defending premiers were at their brilliant best, particularly in the first half, with all the usual suspects standing up and delivering in a big game.

Canterbury’s season on the other hand came to a screeching halt and will no doubt lead to more question marks over their mid-season acquisition of Lachlan Galvin.

PENRITH PANTHERS

1. Dylan Edwards

Safe at the back and had a hand in several tries as the Panthers moved a step closer to the big dance. Rating: 8

2. Paul Alamoti

Justified his selection ahead of Tom Jenkins, scoring three tries and setting up another, giving the Bulldogs’ wide defence nightmares. Rating: 9

Alamoti completes finals hat-trick

3. Izack Tago

His silky hands set the Panthers’ attack out wide alight time and again in the red zone. Rating: 7.5

4. Casey McLean

Like Tago, carved the fragile Bulldogs defence up out wide, combining superbly with To’o. Rating: 8

5. Brian To’o

Looked very much the best winger in the world with two tries, a try assist and an intercept … as well as over 200 run matres. Rating: 9

6. Blaize Talagi

Content to just catch and pass and let his outside men do all the damage with time and space to move. Rating: 7

7. Nathan Cleary

In a glittering career, he may never have played a better finals game. Scored tries, created tries and kicked impeccably. Rating: 9.5

Nathan Cleary celebrates his try.  NRL Photos

8. Moses Leota

The Panthers’ main man up front trampled the Bulldogs pack and came up with some big hits in defence. Rating: 8

22. Mitch Kenny

Made a fine return to the Panthers’ top side, giving good service from dummy-half and creating a try with a clever grubber kick. Rating: 7.5

10. Lindsay Smith

One of the quieter Panthers forwards with the ball but made his presence felt in defence. Rating: 6

11. Scott Sorensen

Also down on his usual attacking game and missed his opposite Jake Preston in the Bulldogs’ first try. Rating: 5.5

12. Liam Martin

Did everything at his usual 100 miles per hour before an injury forced him off in the final five minutes. Rating: 7

Martin forced off with injury

13. Isaah Yeo

Played the perfect link man in attack, topped the tackle count and led the team intelligently. Rating: 8

14. Brad Schneider

Had little impact in his short game time with just one run and a handful of tackles. Rating: 4

15. Liam Henry

Kept the momentum up when he get his chance from the bench. Solid display. Rating: 5.5

16. Isaiah Papali’i

The pick of the Penrith bench men, scoring a try and making over 150 run metres. Rating: 7

17. Luke Garner

Didn’t do much in his half hour of game time, making just three runs. Rating: 4

Watch the 2025 NRL premiership live and free on Nine and 9Now.

CANTERBURY BULLDOGS

1. Connor Tracey

A danger in attack but was caught out badly a couple of times in the last line of defence. Rating: 6

2. Jacob Kiraz

Threatening in attack but gave To’o far too much room to move when the Panthers backline clicked. Rating: 5.5

3. Bronson Xerri

One of the more effective Bulldogs, scoring a try and making a couple of clean line breaks. Rating: 7

Bronson Xerri Getty

4. Matt Burton

In only his second game at left centre this year, got few chances in attack as the Dogs stumbled time and again. Rating: 6

5. Jethro Rinakama

His inexperience showed as he was left flat-footed several times when the Panthers targeted his wing. Rating: 4

6. Lachlan Galvin

The man in the hot seat did well in his new position in a beaten side with a try, two assists and several breaks. Rating: 8

7. Toby Sexton

Very disappointing final game for the Dogs with just two runs for 11 metres and average kicking. Rating: 4

8. Max King

Finished his best season with a solid display but could do nothing to stem the Panthers’ attacking raids. Rating: 6.5

17. Reed Mahoney

Got his big chance back in the starting side but disappointing with just one run out of dummy-half. Rating: 4

Reed Mahoney NRL Images

15. Sitili Tupouniua

Reached triple figures in run metres and also strong in defence. Rating: 6

11. Viliame Kikau

Tried hard but probably not the ideal captain replacement for the injured Stephen Crichton – not a big talker. Rating: 6

12. Jacob Preston

Simply outstanding in a well beaten team – scored a try, set one up, made three line breaks and topped the tackle count. Rating: 9

13. Jaeman Salmon

Made just three runs and missed nine tackles – not good enough in an elimination final. Rating: 3.5

9. Bailey Hayward

Did little better than Mahoney when he got his chance at dummy-half, making a mere three runs. Rating: 4

Josh Curran looks dejected after the loss Getty

10. Josh Curran

Never really got into the game, which was already gone, when he came on from the bench. Rating: 5

14. Kurt Mann

After a great season for the Dogs, was barely sighted when he got his chance as an interchange, such was the Panthers’ domination. Rating: 5

16. Harry Hayes

Tried to lift the attack, but was also found wanting in defence with eight misses as the Panthers ran rampant. Rating: 4.5

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *